Things can rarely be taken at face value, and this is especially true in literature. Meaning can be found in any number of places, and this is especially true when symbols are involved. Symbols can serve not only to reinforce an idea, but also to lend meaning to a work as a whole. In Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman, the breaking of the voice recorder serves as a symbol of the deterioration of Willy Loman's own mind, and forces him to confront the fact that he is not living in reality.
Throughout Death of a Salesman, it is shown again and again that Willy is not sound of mind. He has conversations with his dead brother Ben, constantly contradicts himself, and can't seem to keep his mind out of the past. The past he is trapped in, however, is a flawed one -- Willy is completely unwilling and unable to accurately recall what has actually happened to him due to a life full of lies, both to himself and to his family.
At one point in the play, Willy goes to visit his boss, hoping to ask for a raise and a position in the city. Upon his arrival, he finds that his boss is ignoring him entirely, in favor of playing with a machine that records any sounds it picks up. He demonstrates for Willy how it recorded the various members of his family speaking before leaving the room. Being the curious man that he is, Willy goes over to the machine and, upon touching it, breaks it immediately. This is symbolic of the way Willy's memory is flawed.
The voice recorder is a stark contrast to Willy's mind. Where Willy cannot differentiate between truth and lies, the machine records only what actually happens. The voice recorder is incapable of falsely remembering something. Willy breaks the recorder because he is unable to confront the truth. He is too wrapped up in what he's convinced himself has happened. Shortly after leaving his boss's office, Willy's son Biff attempts to force him to see the truth, but the only thing that happens is that Willy withdraws further into his mind. Biff acts as a sort of living voice recorder, since he is able to accurately remember the past and attempts to make Willy hear it as well. However, by this point Willy's mind is so far gone that Biff cannot bring him back to reality.
Death of a Salesman centers around the failing of Willy Loman's mind and his inability to confront reality. The voice recorder serves as a symbol of the reality that Willy cannot accept, and his breaking it reinforces the idea that his own memory is flawed.
Emma,
ReplyDeleteThis essay explains the recorder as a symbol well. Your organization follows a clear path, so the essay and meaning of your essay is clear. When I saw your prompt, I was skeptical of how much someone could write about a symbol, but you managed to write just enough information to explain the symbol thoroughly. The one thing that could be added is examples of Willy being unreliable before dealing with the recorder, but other than that, it is great.
Your introduction is particularly good. This is always one of the hardest things for me to write. I never really know where to start and what to say to ease the essay along. You manage to bring in a open ended statement the gets the reader interested, and relates clearly to the subject of your essay.
Great job!
Really good essay! I have serious trouble with these essays, I'm really good at writing in a short amount of time but I'm not good at creating an essay that will get me a high score with the AP judges. So I applaud you for creating a really nice essay that is well organized and well explained. Your introduction is really well written, I like how it has more than just a theme statement but still flows really well and gets to the point. I think your examples are well explained and also flow together. I like how you say "Biff acts as a sort of living tape recorder" because it's often easy to miss that when you read the play but it is definitely accurate and I very good thing to point out especially in the context of your essay. Overall you did a really good job on this post!
ReplyDelete